Let me explain the basics of form first. The official name of the forms category of taekwondo is "Poomsae." This is:
"essentially an established pattern of skills that every [practitioner of] Taekwondo should follow
in most universal situations. . . That is, poomsae is a set of fighting technique, so it is acting in relation
to your opponent. Poomsae,
as the optimum way of acting in relation to an opponent, developed not by chance
but through the infinite experience and accumulated wisdom of the ancients.
Therefore, the practitioner of Taekwondo poomsae does not fight alone but with
the wisdom of his forebears." (What Is Poomsae in Taekwondo)
Simply put, when I compete in forms, I and the competitors in my division perform the same poomsae. We are judged based on accuracy and presentation.
The judging for poomsae is extremely complicated. There are 5 or 6 judges total watching one competitor at a time. One watches the feet, another the hands, etc.. A competitor is judged on the accuracy of each movement. Poomsae scoring is a negative scoring system. One starts with 10 full points, and judges mark down for each mistake made. It is nearly impossible to receive a full 10; a good score would be a 7 or higher. Presentation is also a part of the scoring. This is judged on the overall impression the competitor gives. Strength, speed, and confidence are key to score high. 5 points total are allotted for accuracy, and 5 points are allotted for presentation. Each judge's score out of 10 is added with those of the others, then the average of all the scores is the competitor's final score. The person with the highest score wins.
This type of judging usually allows for people with no special qualities to win a competition. You may not think that a competitor will win, but they may actually make the least mistakes and beat a person who seems better. Also, lobbying the judges can help you win a competition. Before the U.S. Open Championships, my coach bought the judges dinner, treated them out, etc... This is not cheating, he says, but just "making sure they judge fairly and not too harshly."
I am still far from being able to place at a national tournament. At the Las Vegas U.S. Open in February, I did not even make the cut to the semi-finals. Hopefully, though I will have improved by the time I get to the Junior Olympics this summer!
Reference: "What Is Poomsae in Taekwondo." What Is Poomsae in Taekwondo. World Cultural Alliance of Taekwondo. Web. 05 May 2012. <http://tkdtrain.cafe24.com/trainings/poomsae/what.html>.